The Good Ol’ Days: Prices From the 1990’s That Will Make You Want to Go Back In Time

By: Calla Conway | Published: Nov 15, 2023

The nineties, what a time to be alive. Grunge music was thriving, prices were low, and the world was at a seemingly mellow and innocuous place (comparatively). And did we mention the prices? Looking at the photos of that golden decade is enough to make anyone want to travel back in time. 

We’ve been waxing nostalgic for times long past, when a trip to the gas pump didn’t cost you and ear and a leg and when the thought of buying a home wasn’t a distant relative of the American dream. Read below to get blown away at how much things have changed. Fair warning, prepare to throw your wallet out the window…

Get That Bread

If you’re following the trend of this article, then you won’t be surprised that the cost of bread was much (much) cheaper than when it was in the nineties. The average price of bread back then was around $1.29. 

Advertisement

Source: SavingAdvice.com

Today, per loaf of bread, you’re looking at spending more than $3.20 to get your peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. 

A Very Cheap Meal

The nineties were also kind to those of us who liked to indulge ourselves in a McDonald’s meal and some french fries. A hamburger? Only $0.89! Or what about the coveted Big Mac? In the nineties they were only around $3.00.

Advertisement

Source: SavingAdvice.com

Today, a Big Mac has an average price of upwards $6.00. While McDonald’s is still considered “cheap food,” there was a time when this was deeply true. That ship has sailed. 

You’ve Got Mail

You more than likely do not have mail in this day and age. At least not the fun kind, like opening the mailbox and seeing a letter from a loved one on vacation who just so happened to use a forever stamp.

Advertisement

Source: SavingAdvice.com

Now, this scenario sounds like more of a nineties scenario and for good reason too. It was before the boom of technology and instant messaging, and also the forever stamp only cost anywhere from $0.33-$0.49. Today, you’ll find the same stamp for upwards $1.15. 

Milking It

Milk has been to American households as dollar bills to a wallet. And yet, this has not been able to keep the prices of the famed beverage down. In the nineties, a gallon of milk went for $0.99 to $1.00. Not too bad.

Advertisement

Source: SavingAdvice.com

Today, the same gallon of milk can cost upwards of $3.16. That is a pretty penny for some milk!

Cheap Nineties Gas

It almost hurts to look at, doesn’t it? This gorgeous throwback of dirt cheap gas prices. What a time to be an American driver! On the road, not a care in the world. Why? Because you can afford to hit the gas and take it all in. 

Source: SavingAdvice.com

We aren’t trying to rub in. It hurts us too. Given that the average price of gas is trending upwards more and more everyday and that $5.00 barely gets you around the block, yes we mourn the nineties. 

Advertisement

Cheaper By The Dozen? Not Quite

Back in the golden era of spending (the nineties) you could get one dozen eggs for the beautiful cost of $0.99. You could eat eggs for a week and then some on a buck!

Source: SavingAdvice.com

The price has more than doubled, and that also depends on whether or not you want the cage free, the free range, the free range on a farm, etc. Best wishes.

Advertisement

Get In Loser, We’re Not Going Shopping (It’s Too Pricey)

While many of us wouldn’t dream of buying a new car in this day and age (what is so wrong with used?) there was a time when it wasn’t an out of this world notion. Back in the heyday of the American economy, the average price for a car was typically about $9,437-$13,600.

Source: SavingAdvice.com

Today, the average price for a brand new car sits somewhere around $36,270. So that’s cool. On top of that, even used cars are incredibly expensive. Guess we’ll walk. 

Advertisement

Buying A Home?

The American Dream was built on the idea that one day you’ll own a home with your beautiful family on your beautiful property and live a sweet and prosperous life. Ahh, what a time. In the nineties the average price to own a home was around $79,100.

Source: SavingAdvice.com

Today, that number has skyrocketed. By 2018, the average cost to own a home sits at $217,300. 

Advertisement

Apples To Apples

In the nineties, one could get an entire pound of apples for $0.99. The average apple weighs between 150 and 250 grams, and there are about 454 grams in a pound. Not too shabby.

Source: SavingAdvice.com

However, nowadays a pound of apples can run up to $1.44 per pound which really sets the average American back on how many apples a household can get compared to the nineties decade. 

Advertisement

90s Phones vs. Modern Devices

You may be surprised to learn that phones from the 90s cost way more than phones today. Back then, a phone like the Simon Personal Communicator cost around $900, which would be worth around $2,100 today. Although the phone came with many functions, we certainly can’t compare it to what phones today can do. 

Source: Pinterest

Today, with as little as $500, you can get a good phone, and if you have around $1000, you can get an even better phone like an iPhone. 

Advertisement

Soaring Higher Education Costs

Anyone paying tuition these days deserves all the respect they can get. In the 90s, people used to pay an average of $3,349 for a public 4-year institution tuition, and for private, around $15,160. Fast forward to today, you will find more people buried in student loans than those who can pay in full.

Source: Getty Images

Nowadays, it has gone up to around an average of $38,768 per year for private schools and $26,027 for public. These days, people surely have to think twice before they go to school. 

Advertisement

Sizzling Bacon

Bacon is absolutely delicious, but recent prices are making fewer people indulge in this delight. What used to be $1.90 per pound in the 90s has gone up to around $7-$8 per pound. These prices are practically pushing people away because many people often choose not to buy them when they go shopping.

Source: John Monroe/Facebook

If you are a sucker for bacon but want to manage costs, think about stocking up during a sale. This might save you a lot!

Advertisement

For The Love Of Movies

One industry that has grown over the years is the movie industry, and as it continues to grow, you can only expect that prices will go up too. Movie tickets in the past used to cost around $6; now, people need to pay about $11.57- $28 to watch movies. 

Source: r/90s/Reddit

Although movie stars and movies will come and go, the persisting trend of rising ticket prices seems to be here to stay.

Advertisement

Skyrocketing Rent Prices

Modern-day and the hiking rent craze are making it much harder for people to be able to afford renting houses. In the past, the average rent nationwide was around $447, and now it has gone up to a median rent of $1,879 as of last year. 

Source: Getty Images

This is why you may find people living in ridiculously tiny houses because that’s what they can afford. Some others opt to live with their parents for as long as they can. 

Advertisement